If I go with that 285 40 18 tire on a 10" wheel, is that going to look too short in the rear wheel well, or should I bump it up to 19" or 20" on all four?
OP is your car a manual or auto? Just curious.
Those were Ford's OE sizes for the 2008-ish GT500, on 9.5" wide wheels (+45 offset IIRC).Look's like 255 45 18 front and 285 40 18 rear will be within about one tenth of each other height wise.
Any clearance problems on those front tires? Suspension is stock.