Dont feel too bad, one of my four wheels showed up like this
Now I get to find out just how good their customer service is...
Having been through a similar issue, I can attest to AM's customer support being good although, it was a pain in the arse.
Ordered four Forgestar 19x10 CF5's over 2016 Black Friday and two wheels showed up damaged (one bent, one with several gouges around the barrel lip). AM wanted pics of wheels and boxes, then sent two new wheels out.
The two new wheels were the wrong color and one was bent. The boxes had the original color crossed out and the new color listed on a sticker. AM wanted pics of wheels and boxes, then sent two new wheels out.
The next two new wheels arrived and were the right color but one was badly dented. AM wanted pics of the wheel and box, then sent a new wheel out.
The last wheel arrived and was the right color with no apparent damage.
A couple weeks later, took the wheels and tires to my favorite mount and balance shop. As I always do with new wheels, I have the shop spin them on the balance machine to check for any runout. Sure enough, one wheel had excessive lateral runout and measured at .272" at the bead. All the other wheels had less than .01" in both lateral and radial directions.
AM sent another wheel out after New Years and it was spot on without any issues.
I commented to AM that they should double box their wheels like I've seen other places do to reduce the possibilities of damage from shipping.