Bogging/stalling when coming to a stop, irregular power.

partypants

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2022
Posts
38
Reaction score
0
Location
Florida
So I left work a couple of weeks ago and my car felt/sounded off. It feels like its choked up, almost as if I short shifted and the car needed to afterfire and clear out, until around ~3000rpm. Then a few days ago, as I pulled into work, I got the wrench light and a code for TPS, and saw a code for an O2 sensor stuck rich. On the way home, my car stalled a few times as I came to a stop at red lights and before I pulled into my driveway. Now, since I bought the car last July Ive thought it was running rich, but never had any issues until recently. I just replaced the TPS, and it still bogs/stalls when I come to a stop, but the code went away before I even installed it.
Car is an 08 GT, with a bunch of mods that the previous owner installed. Borla exhaust, CAI, Ford racing manifold, MSD coil packs, BBK throttle body, headers and its cammed.
Any help would be appreciated.
 
Last edited:

RRPD4130

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2021
Posts
10
Reaction score
1
Location
The Last Citadel of Freedom-Great State of Texas
I am slowly writing up my bizarro engine death that occurred July 2021 and required 3 months for my Lincoln dealership to locate a longblock ; nutshell, a 2020 purchase, from the usual local suspects, an OEM Motorcraft over-the-counter replacement Fuel Rail Pressure Sensor. One year later, my engine autopsy evidenced that the recycled Shenzhen Schmoo plastic sensor disintegrated inside the fuel rail itself, during a cold start and subsequent non-start OBD2 diagnostics....every fuel pump cycle/charge pumped the cylinders full of petrol. DRT. Dead Right There.
First symptom was what you describe, precisely.
I have found zero other similar accounts, except for a Corvette forum.
Just a hope. Good luck, my friend.
 

stkjock

---- Madmin ----
Staff member
Administrator
Super Moderator
S197 Team Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2007
Posts
40,243
Reaction score
3,159
Location
Long Island NY
Post all the actual codes

do you know who’s tune is in the car?
 

thailand

forum member
Joined
Jan 13, 2012
Posts
136
Reaction score
18
Location
MontCo, PA
Mine did that when I had a dirty throttle body. Once cleaned, all was well.
I've also read folks having issues with BBK...if any of the codes were throttle body/motor related.
 

Bigmatthew86

Junior Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2021
Posts
26
Reaction score
17
Location
South Carolina
I’d start by giving the throttle body & good cleaning & maf too. Might not do a thing but worth a shot. I’d also hit up Lito & get a tune from him. It made a big difference on my car that has only & intake & axle backs. So it could make a gigantic difference on your car with everything it has done.
 

partypants

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2022
Posts
38
Reaction score
0
Location
Florida
Mine did that when I had a dirty throttle body. Once cleaned, all was well.
I've also read folks having issues with BBK...if any of the codes were throttle body/motor related.
I cleaned the throttle body a few days before the limp mode, tps sensor etc. As for the BBK thing, IDK, it kind of came out of nowhere. Ive had the car since last July, and havent had any issues up until all this.

I’d start by giving the throttle body & good cleaning & maf too. Might not do a thing but worth a shot. I’d also hit up Lito & get a tune from him. It made a big difference on my car that has only & intake & axle backs. So it could make a gigantic difference on your car with everything it has done.
I cleaned both last week. When I have the money for a tune, Im taking it to get dyno tuned by a guy near me who did all of my old bosses mustangs.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

partypants

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2022
Posts
38
Reaction score
0
Location
Florida
I am slowly writing up my bizarro engine death that occurred July 2021 and required 3 months for my Lincoln dealership to locate a longblock ; nutshell, a 2020 purchase, from the usual local suspects, an OEM Motorcraft over-the-counter replacement Fuel Rail Pressure Sensor. One year later, my engine autopsy evidenced that the recycled Shenzhen Schmoo plastic sensor disintegrated inside the fuel rail itself, during a cold start and subsequent non-start OBD2 diagnostics....every fuel pump cycle/charge pumped the cylinders full of petrol. DRT. Dead Right There.
First symptom was what you describe, precisely.
I have found zero other similar accounts, except for a Corvette forum.
Just a hope. Good luck, my friend.
Im confused, are you saying a bad fuel rail pressure sensor is what killed your engine?
 

DieHarder

Senior Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2019
Posts
1,467
Reaction score
758
Not sure if this will help you or not. Just what I could find in the books.

Since you replaced the TPS those concerns should be gone unless you're still getting codes for it. For a P2196 - In the Powertrain Control manual go to Section H - Pin Point testing. The tests for that involve Fuel control systems and subsystems.

Test steps
According to the manual for a P2196 go to H8: https://iihs.net/fsm/?d=38&f=Fuel Control.pdf&p=15; then H9; followed by H14 (for 2196); then H16 or H15 (depending on results looking at fuel pressure and associated systems); and continue until you narrow down the issue or find/repair the problem.

Unfortunately, the online manual is incomplete with a majority of other Section H's Pinpoint tests missing (at least compared to the paper manuals).
 

Rick Simons

Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2019
Posts
250
Reaction score
61
Whose CAI are you running? I had a JLT that I bought as part of a package deal with the SCT tuner. Several months after installing it the motor started acting funny (well, strangely, it wasn't that funny after all). Cruising at 60-70 it would all of a sudden act as though the key was turned of. I'd let off the throttle, then it would come back on. It did this about 4 times during that drive cycle. It also developed a stumble just off of idle. No MIL (wrench light) though...
Looking into it I found that the mounting surface for the MAF sensor on the JLT intake wasn't even close to flat, and that there was a sizeable vacuum leak at there. I put the stock intake back on, Lito adjusted my tune, and I haven't looked back. The JLT is currently on a shelf gathering dust.
 

GlassTop09

Senior Member
Joined
May 24, 2019
Posts
1,142
Reaction score
525
Location
Farmington, NM
As for the BBK thing, IDK, it kind of came out of nowhere.
Hi OP,
Just so you know, these BBK #1763 62mm TB's can have an issue w\ excess drag or hang in the plastic TB gearing on the actuator side which will show up mostly close to idle position (this is where the butterfly shaft return spring is at its weakest coil tension). I know this because I've owned 1 of these in the past & have witnessed it 1st hand when I was swapping out the TPS & actuator from my OEM TB onto it. It's an easy issue to fix by using some white lithium grease (safe to be used on plastic\nylon gearing) to lube the plastic gearing teeth (I've applied this myself) to eliminate this from happening.
Most of these BBK TB's get assembled w\o any application of some lube on these gears (as the instructions state to do) but I've witnessed the need for it to be used so keep this in mind.

Not saying yours has this particular issue......

If you're still having the car stall when coming to a stop (APP is at full rest--foot off the pedal--sending idle voltage signals to PCM) & you have replaced the TPS sensor, then disconnect the battery to clear out the KAM in PCM then do a throttle idle relearn to allow the PCM to relearn\realign the APP to TPS voltage signals then see if this stops the stalling (what the P2135 DTC code is.....PCM detected a difference of the A\B signal between the 2 which says the APP is out of synch electrically w\ the TPS) then go from there. You also might check the TPS connector terminals for contact\corrosion if you haven't already done so. Butterfly shaft drag\sticking can cause this as well........but I'd only look into this if the idle relearn didn't help. Don't leave out the APP either.........these cars are getting old enough for some APP sensors to start failing.

The P2196 code is due to the B1S1 O2 sensor getting hung momentarily rich (O2 sensor output voltage above 700mV & voltage is not switching lower) when PCM is running lean response tests on the O2 sensor (PCM has cut fuel to lean out exhaust but O2 sensor hasn't responded\reacted from the rich position to the lean exhaust within a specific period of time) thus the DTC.
Before looking at anything else I'd suggest checking the B1S1 O2 sensor to make sure that the sensor itself isn't the cause before looking at fueling because it all starts w\ the O2 sensor's voltage feedback signal to the PCM. Once you determine that the B1S1 O2 sensor is physically good & physically operating properly, then start looking at\for fueling issues.

Just swap sides (B1S1 w\ B2S1) w\ O2 sensors then see if the DTC moves to B2 (P2198 DTC shows up).

Hope this can help you out.
 

whitmanink

Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2020
Posts
204
Reaction score
41
Location
denver pa
sounds like vvt solenoid sticking ,,,,, isnt that what causes this condition? the ford mikoloko guy was talking about this in an old video ,
 

Dino Dino Bambino

I have a red car
Joined
Aug 11, 2014
Posts
3,903
Reaction score
1,768
Location
Cyprus
So I left work a couple of weeks ago and my car felt/sounded off. It feels like its choked up, almost as if I short shifted and the car needed to afterfire and clear out, until around ~3000rpm. Then a few days ago, as I pulled into work, I got the wrench light and a code for TPS, and saw a code for an O2 sensor stuck rich. On the way home, my car stalled a few times as I came to a stop at red lights and before I pulled into my driveway. Now, since I bought the car last July Ive thought it was running rich, but never had any issues until recently. I just replaced the TPS, and it still bogs/stalls when I come to a stop, but the code went away before I even installed it.
Car is an 08 GT, with a bunch of mods that the previous owner installed. Borla exhaust, CAI, Ford racing manifold, MSD coil packs, BBK throttle body, headers and its cammed.
Any help would be appreciated.

Here's a very good description of the problem and the possible solutions:

https://www.obd-codes.com/p2135

The P2196 rich code was most likely triggered by the throttle body problem, so I second @GlassTop09 's suggestion to grease the gears inside the TB actuator.

sounds like vvt solenoid sticking ,,,,, isnt that what causes this condition? the ford mikoloko guy was talking about this in an old video ,

Yes, a sticking VCT solenoid can also cause similar symptoms plus an uneven idle but you'd also have a cam position sensor code on the corresponding cylinder bank.
 

partypants

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2022
Posts
38
Reaction score
0
Location
Florida
Hi OP,
Just so you know, these BBK #1763 62mm TB's can have an issue w\ excess drag or hang in the plastic TB gearing on the actuator side which will show up mostly close to idle position (this is where the butterfly shaft return spring is at its weakest coil tension). I know this because I've owned 1 of these in the past & have witnessed it 1st hand when I was swapping out the TPS & actuator from my OEM TB onto it. It's an easy issue to fix by using some white lithium grease (safe to be used on plastic\nylon gearing) to lube the plastic gearing teeth (I've applied this myself) to eliminate this from happening.
Most of these BBK TB's get assembled w\o any application of some lube on these gears (as the instructions state to do) but I've witnessed the need for it to be used so keep this in mind.

Not saying yours has this particular issue......

If you're still having the car stall when coming to a stop (APP is at full rest--foot off the pedal--sending idle voltage signals to PCM) & you have replaced the TPS sensor, then disconnect the battery to clear out the KAM in PCM then do a throttle idle relearn to allow the PCM to relearn\realign the APP to TPS voltage signals then see if this stops the stalling (what the P2135 DTC code is.....PCM detected a difference of the A\B signal between the 2 which says the APP is out of synch electrically w\ the TPS) then go from there. You also might check the TPS connector terminals for contact\corrosion if you haven't already done so. Butterfly shaft drag\sticking can cause this as well........but I'd only look into this if the idle relearn didn't help. Don't leave out the APP either.........these cars are getting old enough for some APP sensors to start failing.

The P2196 code is due to the B1S1 O2 sensor getting hung momentarily rich (O2 sensor output voltage above 700mV & voltage is not switching lower) when PCM is running lean response tests on the O2 sensor (PCM has cut fuel to lean out exhaust but O2 sensor hasn't responded\reacted from the rich position to the lean exhaust within a specific period of time) thus the DTC.
Before looking at anything else I'd suggest checking the B1S1 O2 sensor to make sure that the sensor itself isn't the cause before looking at fueling because it all starts w\ the O2 sensor's voltage feedback signal to the PCM. Once you determine that the B1S1 O2 sensor is physically good & physically operating properly, then start looking at\for fueling issues.

Just swap sides (B1S1 w\ B2S1) w\ O2 sensors then see if the DTC moves to B2 (P2198 DTC shows up).

Hope this can help you out.

Im not sure about the throttle body thing, Ill have to look into it. I have been driving my moms car but I did take my car to a family friends shop who couldnt help me because all of the work done to my car, he told me to take it to a tuner because they would know more about what theyre looking at. I took it to a guy my boss has been to for multiple cars (he specializes in Mustangs) who told me everything Im describing sounds like a bad tune. So in the 2-2.5 hours of driving to these places, I still bogged, but not nearly as bad (only down to maybe 600rpm, 500 at worst) and never stalled. My uncles said repeatedly that he thinks I need to get it retuned but also mentioned changing my spark plugs, which Im terrified to do because of the whole spark plug ordeal. I have disconnected the battery but not since doing the TPS. Another thing worth mentioning is that I looked at the data stream on my scanner, and with the car off, foot off the pedal, the throttle percentage sat at 17%. Pedal fully depressed, it went to 75%. If I let off the pedal, it dropped down to ~11%, then jumped back up to rest at 17%. Any thoughts on that?

Also could you point out on a picture where youre telling me to grease? Im not a mechanic and I only know how to do basic stuff so Im not sure what youre telling me to do.
 

GlassTop09

Senior Member
Joined
May 24, 2019
Posts
1,142
Reaction score
525
Location
Farmington, NM
Im not sure about the throttle body thing, Ill have to look into it. I have been driving my moms car but I did take my car to a family friends shop who couldnt help me because all of the work done to my car, he told me to take it to a tuner because they would know more about what theyre looking at. I took it to a guy my boss has been to for multiple cars (he specializes in Mustangs) who told me everything Im describing sounds like a bad tune. So in the 2-2.5 hours of driving to these places, I still bogged, but not nearly as bad (only down to maybe 600rpm, 500 at worst) and never stalled. My uncles said repeatedly that he thinks I need to get it retuned but also mentioned changing my spark plugs, which Im terrified to do because of the whole spark plug ordeal. I have disconnected the battery but not since doing the TPS. Another thing worth mentioning is that I looked at the data stream on my scanner, and with the car off, foot off the pedal, the throttle percentage sat at 17%. Pedal fully depressed, it went to 75%. If I let off the pedal, it dropped down to ~11%, then jumped back up to rest at 17%. Any thoughts on that?

Also could you point out on a picture where youre telling me to grease? Im not a mechanic and I only know how to do basic stuff so Im not sure what youre telling me to do.
1. I read someone has suggested that the tune may be an issue, but if I read your postings correctly that you had none of these issues occurring until recently, then this says to me that your tune isn't the issue & most likely the BBK TB isn't the issue either from a mechanical POV. Your issue is most likely an input signal to PCM issue throwing the PCM output off causing erratic engine operation.......can be several items that need to be checked.
2. Now from the PCM kicking out a P2135 DTC this was indicating a TB to APP synch issue thru PCM. You've replaced the TPS sensor on the BBK TB, is the replacement a MotorCraft OEM part or an aftermarket part? I noted that you typed that this P2135 DTC went away prior you replacing the TPS, correct? If so, then this says to me that this issue is intermittent. Either way, 1st thing to do is to clear KAM & perform an idle relearn to allow the PCM to realign itself to the APP\TPS voltage output to get this out of the way (costs you nothing). The readings you saw thru live data when cycling the APP during KOEO was the TB actuator operation read thru the TPS position......the readings are normal for what you did.....initial TB open angle is around 17%-18% (cold start TB position set by the PCM, not the APP). The rest is the PCM moving the TB according to the APP input.....the TB open % angle followed the APP depressed fully to 75% TB open angle then down to the idle position of 11% when APP was released, then the PCM reset the TB angle back to the cold start TB open position of 17% since you never initiated an engine startup (in KOEO). You'd need to perform the KAM reset\idle relearn w\ new TPS installed 1st then clean TB as needed then verify stall is still present before going further..............
3. The PCM having a P2196 DTC is more of a concern to me. The intermittent TB operating issue could have influenced the B1S1 O2 sensor to momentarily hang rich, but this IMHO is more common to occur during a cold start or coming out of a DFSO (decel fuel shut off) event when the PCM is most likely to be running O2 sensor self check tests (PCM does constantly monitor O2 sensor operations from startup to shutdown). Is this P2196 DTC still showing in PCM? Have you cleared this DTC & checked to see if it has come back? You can test this by swapping both front O2 sensors across banks to see if the DTC moves to the other bank (follows the original B1S1 O2 sensor setting a P2198 DTC) OR if you have a spare known good front NB O2 sensor in hand, use it to replace B1S1 to test if stall goes away. You'd need to verify that the front O2 sensor(s) is working properly before going further (exhaust feedback input controls fueling correction to MAF reading).

You can check other input sensors like the MAF sensor for trash\dirt on sensor element as well & clean as needed then check MAF seal to aftermarket CAI MAF flange for leakage and\or check EVAP CPV operation (check for valve sealing off when PCM signals it closed.....leaking EVAP CPV can cause a vacuum leak thru EVAP canister. This part rarely gets looked at thus is overlooked a lot).

Stuff to consider..............
 

Juice

forum member
Joined
Aug 24, 2017
Posts
4,622
Reaction score
1,904
I seem to vaguely recall issues like this with the BBK TBs.

I suggest just putting a known good, and unmolested stock TB on. And have your tuner restore stock TB data in the tune (if it was tune required, IDK) No need to go to the tuner, have him email you the updated tune.

This is the quickest way I see to either fix the car or eliminate the TB as the issue.
 

partypants

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2022
Posts
38
Reaction score
0
Location
Florida
1. I read someone has suggested that the tune may be an issue, but if I read your postings correctly that you had none of these issues occurring until recently, then this says to me that your tune isn't the issue & most likely the BBK TB isn't the issue either from a mechanical POV. Your issue is most likely an input signal to PCM issue throwing the PCM output off causing erratic engine operation.......can be several items that need to be checked.
2. Now from the PCM kicking out a P2135 DTC this was indicating a TB to APP synch issue thru PCM. You've replaced the TPS sensor on the BBK TB, is the replacement a MotorCraft OEM part or an aftermarket part? I noted that you typed that this P2135 DTC went away prior you replacing the TPS, correct? If so, then this says to me that this issue is intermittent. Either way, 1st thing to do is to clear KAM & perform an idle relearn to allow the PCM to realign itself to the APP\TPS voltage output to get this out of the way (costs you nothing). The readings you saw thru live data when cycling the APP during KOEO was the TB actuator operation read thru the TPS position......the readings are normal for what you did.....initial TB open angle is around 17%-18% (cold start TB position set by the PCM, not the APP). The rest is the PCM moving the TB according to the APP input.....the TB open % angle followed the APP depressed fully to 75% TB open angle then down to the idle position of 11% when APP was released, then the PCM reset the TB angle back to the cold start TB open position of 17% since you never initiated an engine startup (in KOEO). You'd need to perform the KAM reset\idle relearn w\ new TPS installed 1st then clean TB as needed then verify stall is still present before going further..............
3. The PCM having a P2196 DTC is more of a concern to me. The intermittent TB operating issue could have influenced the B1S1 O2 sensor to momentarily hang rich, but this IMHO is more common to occur during a cold start or coming out of a DFSO (decel fuel shut off) event when the PCM is most likely to be running O2 sensor self check tests (PCM does constantly monitor O2 sensor operations from startup to shutdown). Is this P2196 DTC still showing in PCM? Have you cleared this DTC & checked to see if it has come back? You can test this by swapping both front O2 sensors across banks to see if the DTC moves to the other bank (follows the original B1S1 O2 sensor setting a P2198 DTC) OR if you have a spare known good front NB O2 sensor in hand, use it to replace B1S1 to test if stall goes away. You'd need to verify that the front O2 sensor(s) is working properly before going further (exhaust feedback input controls fueling correction to MAF reading).

You can check other input sensors like the MAF sensor for trash\dirt on sensor element as well & clean as needed then check MAF seal to aftermarket CAI MAF flange for leakage and\or check EVAP CPV operation (check for valve sealing off when PCM signals it closed.....leaking EVAP CPV can cause a vacuum leak thru EVAP canister. This part rarely gets looked at thus is overlooked a lot).

Stuff to consider..............
The 02 sensor code has been gone, cleaned MAF last month. Im in a bit of a situation, I did the spark plugs yesterday and none of them broke thankfully. Unfortunately what did break was one of the bolts that hold the coil packs in. I did disconnect the battery while doing this, but now I need to figure out how to get this broken bolt out. I started it up to see how it would idle, but I got a code, obviously, for the coil pack as it isnt full seated without being bolted in.
 

partypants

Junior Member
Joined
Feb 6, 2022
Posts
38
Reaction score
0
Location
Florida
I seem to vaguely recall issues like this with the BBK TBs.

I suggest just putting a known good, and unmolested stock TB on. And have your tuner restore stock TB data in the tune (if it was tune required, IDK) No need to go to the tuner, have him email you the updated tune.

This is the quickest way I see to either fix the car or eliminate the TB as the issue.
I dont know who tuned the car, I bought the car as is with everything thats been done to it last July.
 

Latest posts

Support us!

Support Us - Become A Supporting Member Today!

Click Here For Details

Sponsor Links

Banner image
Back
Top