Had a great time in NYC!
On the second day, we spent most of our time at Liberty and Ellis Island. Then we went to Seaport, a few brews in Heartland Brewery, then went on a search for the best slice on NY style pizza. Famous Joe's Pizza had a lot of famous celebrities and politician pictures on the walls, but the pizza was just OK. We then tried Abitino's Pizza and thought that was a little better. Finished up day two on the 17th floor roof bar of our hotel, with great views of the Chrysler Building, Empire State Building, and the East River.
Day three we started out at the Today Show at NBC. Didn't get on TV, but it was cool watching them tape the show from outside the window of Studio 1A right on the street corner. Went to get some breakfast and then started our trek out to Yankee Stadium to catch a game. Really awesome being in Yankee stadium watching the game. Had some Goose Creek IPA at $12 a cup, but at least they were big cups (23oz?). Next we went to snag some tickets at Times Square at the TKTS counter. Line was long, but moving fast, got some seats for Zarkana, Circus de Soleil in the Orchestra only 7 rows from the stage for 75 each. We couldn't believe our luck, folks around us paid triple that for their seats. While waiting for the show, got the world's biggest and best Reuben at Carnegie Deli. Highly recommend splitting one with someone, just get extra bread and try to save room for a slice of Cheescake. Went to the show and sipped on a $10 Jack and Coke while watching Zarkana. Radio City Music Hall is awesome, highly recommend a visit there.
Then, the next morning we got the hell out of dodge. Gave away our unlimited bus passes (good for 3 more days) to the bus driver when we got the airport. Now need to save up for our next trip next year.
Thanks again for all the tips and advice on here. Made our trip go much smoother and knew what to expect.