Just throwing this out there. Do you know for certain that you are hitting max intended boost at the strip?
I ask this because my Procharger needed an extremely tight belt tensioner (it had it's own tensioner) to reach max boost. Others have had this same issue. It's very difficult to monitor boost when driving and maybe you aren't seeing the same boost as has been previously thought.
IAT's run a little hot with a D1, not sure about your P1 but they are almost the same blower. IIRC I would see just about 150 IAT measured at the intercooler with the D1 at 19psi.
In any case you should be having more mph unless the boost is going somewhere else. This shouldn't be a major issue, imo it will be something simple. The big deal will be figuring it out.