From http://www.reischeperformance.com/
Whether you are using an aftermarket radiator or not these thermostats will provide the best possible coolant temps and heat dissipation from your setup along with reduced warm up times and better cold weather performance when compared to a t-stat with holes drilled in the diaphragm. I believe the 170° opening temp is the ideal balance for high performance engines, providing high flow to your radiator by mid-180 temps while still maintaining a decent level of all season performance. With proper fan settings your cruising temps in cool weather will be in the 170s and in hot weather the 180s, giving those running high levels of timing and/or boost added protection against engine damaging detonation as well as maximum power output.
Here you see the OEM thermostat from an ’03 Cobra (left) next to my 4.6L DOHC t-stat (right) and how they respond to the same temperature water. More...
He's comparing apples to grapefruit. You have to take into account WHERE the t-stat is located as well.