So my mechanic says its a timing chain issue and the engine should be swapped. Strange as I put this motor in last March. It's weird. The car there's no dirty oil with would be symptoms of metal getting into engine parts. I'm at a lost as two motor swaps within 1.4 years. I'd love some opinion's here as they gave me a border line ChatGPT response.
My Question: What were the symptoms you saw that lead to timing chain being the culprit? Can we not swap out the timing chain and move to re-synchronization next? Are you seeing damage to other engine components?
Mechanic: :However, based on the symptoms found during the diagnostic process, there is a considerable possibility of internal engine damage caused by the timing failure. The evidence observed includes: * Excessive slack in the timing chains; * Engine timing significantly out of synchronization; * Air blowing back through the intake manifold during cranking; * No-start condition; * This engine model is considered an interference engine, meaning that when timing falls out of specification, there is a possibility of contact between valves and pistons. When this occurs, possible damage may include: * Bent valves; * Cracked or damaged pistons; * Damage to internal cylinder head components. Regarding the "wear" comment, we are not necessarily referring to the previously replaced engine itself or to the engine age. Our concern is primarily related to the wear/failure found in the timing system components, especially due to the extremely loose timing chains observed during inspection. At this time, no excessive metal contamination was identified in the oil, and no visible external damage to the engine block was found. However, this does not eliminate the possibility of internal damage to the valves, pistons, or cylinder heads. As for the probability of the engine operating properly after only replacing the timing components, unfortunately it is not possible to provide an exact percentage without complete teardown and further testing. There is a possibility the engine may run properly after timing correction, but there is also a significant risk that internal damage may already exist and only become evident after full reassembly and engine synchronization. For this reason, we are unable to provide warranty coverage on a partial timing repair alone. The repair process requires extensive front engine disassembly, replacement of timing components, and complete engine timing setup. If bent valves or other internal engine damage are discovered after reassembly, the engine would require additional teardown and repairs. Our labor rate is currently $130 per hour. Based on labor cost, parts cost, and the level of risk involved, our technical recommendation was complete engine replacement, as in many cases this becomes the safest, most reliable, and most cost-effective solution compared to attempting a partial repair without warranty.
Thoughts?