actually, ford stretches the tires from the factory...the 255/45/18 belongs on an 8.5 in wide rim...and the same with the gt500, the 255/45/18 on there is stretched, as a 275/40/18 belongs on there as far as the width of the rim goes...so honestly you are just putting what belongs on there
ford did stretch the tire for a reason though...due to the larger side walls on the new mustangs, stretching the tire allows for better steering response at the cost of a small amount of grip...
you will slow down the steering response slightly, but you will increase the peak grip overall and actually you will also increase the ride comfort too