FINALLY!!!

Adam@ST

Member
Official Vendor
Joined
Apr 24, 2007
Posts
283
Reaction score
4
good numbers

Congrats on the good numbers. Glad to see the problem is cured.
 

Clay

Member
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2007
Posts
321
Reaction score
3
Location
Waco, TX
Congrats on the PCM fix. How much timing are you running hawg? A/F? Also, no problems or chatter with my centerforce df as of yet.
 

Hawgman

THE fucking bad guy
Staff member
Administrator
Super Moderator
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2007
Posts
14,472
Reaction score
954
Location
Texas
Max timing is 17*. A/F is 11.6. On pump gas.
 

MrClean

Marc; but I go by MrClean
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2007
Posts
2,745
Reaction score
5
Location
Friendswood, TX
Nice numbers, Hawg. I wonder what your 0-60 mph time is on the street.
A couple more questions:
  • Is your motor built, or are you running stock internals?
  • Why does everyone refer to the Saleen SC an "the old fart's" SC...isn't it a twin screw type like the Whipple? If anything, the Roush Roots-type would be the "old fashioned" version...
 

Hawgman

THE fucking bad guy
Staff member
Administrator
Super Moderator
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2007
Posts
14,472
Reaction score
954
Location
Texas
Did your warranty cover it?
:funnypost:
Good to hear. Where in Texas are you?
East of you.. Plano area.
Nice numbers, Hawg. I wonder what your 0-60 mph time is on the street.
A couple more questions:
  • Is your motor built, or are you running stock internals?
  • Why does everyone refer to the Saleen SC an "the old fart's" SC...isn't it a twin screw type like the Whipple? If anything, the Roush Roots-type would be the "old fashioned" version...
On the street? No idea. I normally don't heat the tires and lower the pressure on the street :)
  • Stock motor. Been running basically this same power for well over a year. Had the SC for over 2 years now.
  • It's mostly an inside joke/friendly rivalry among internet friends. Kenne Bell Vs. Saleen thing. Basically, the Saleen is a 2.3L blower. When it came out all everyone heard was how the KB was going to be superior. Yet KB has had to increase their displacement twice before getting the same power with the same PSI.
 

psfracer

billy badass
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2007
Posts
10,917
Reaction score
82
Location
Valencia, CA
Holy F'n shit----I have read through all 3 of Hawgmans threads and I may be experiencing the same problem.

Problem is getting progressively worse. Start up the car, car will idle smooth, but then after a minute or so, the a/f will go to 16 then 17, then off the scale for a few seconds, then pop back to 14-15 at idle. Drive around in stop and go traffic and at totally random times, same thing, will accelerate lightly and the a/f will go off the scale lean for a few seconds, then pop back to 13-14 and I accelerate normally. I already replaced the o2 sensors and checked for vacum leaks. Unlike Docs problem, mine will also do that at WOT, a/f will go to 11.X, then go all the way lean 17+ and I will have to lift. After lifting, it will continue to read off the scale lean for a few seconds, then pop back to 14-15 a/f. At a steady cruise its fine. Based on the other threads I read, I may need a new PCM. :thud:

Doc, this sounds like the problem you had, right??
 

05mustang_TT_charged

Because Race Car!!
S197 Team Member
Joined
Nov 2, 2007
Posts
2,355
Reaction score
5
Location
LSU Country
i am having the same problem. i have been chaseing it down with my tuner for a year, i may try a new computer also
 

Hawgman

THE fucking bad guy
Staff member
Administrator
Super Moderator
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2007
Posts
14,472
Reaction score
954
Location
Texas
Holy F'n shit----I have read through all 3 of Hawgmans threads and I may be experiencing the same problem.

Problem is getting progressively worse. Start up the car, car will idle smooth, but then after a minute or so, the a/f will go to 16 then 17, then off the scale for a few seconds, then pop back to 14-15 at idle. Drive around in stop and go traffic and at totally random times, same thing, will accelerate lightly and the a/f will go off the scale lean for a few seconds, then pop back to 13-14 and I accelerate normally. I already replaced the o2 sensors and checked for vacum leaks. Unlike Docs problem, mine will also do that at WOT, a/f will go to 11.X, then go all the way lean 17+ and I will have to lift. After lifting, it will continue to read off the scale lean for a few seconds, then pop back to 14-15 a/f. At a steady cruise its fine. Based on the other threads I read, I may need a new PCM. :thud:

Doc, this sounds like the problem you had, right??

Unfortunately this sound quite a bit like the problem I was having. See if you can get an open loop version of your tune. If so, try that and see if the problem quits (or at least dramatically decreases). Might help in the diagnosis.

I do have one word of advice. Don't screw around with aftermarket companies that offer you a rebuild on your PCM. Just bite the bullet and order a replacement from a dealer. KC over at TMS can probably give you a close to cost deal on one if ya ask. They will order it with the VIN from your car and it will be just as your was from the factory. Only thing that the dealer will need to do is flash the PATS.

If you and 05mustang_kb_charged both have the same issue, these two will make #5 and #6 I have heard of (including mine) that has had this problem. Adam had an issue with one that was doing the same thing also.

Not sure if it makes any difference or not, but the only cars I know of that have seen something like this were supercharged cars. Then again, I doubt if a NA guy would know since most don't run a wideband on a NA car.

Not to jinx anything... but mine has sort of been doing it again. Not nearly to the extreme it was doing it, but I have noticed over the last couple of weeks that it has been leaning out when I let off the gas. If I push the clutch in it doesn't do it. But if I just let off and coast in gear it does. And the length of time it does it depends on how hard I was in the throttle before I let off. The harder I was in it, the longer it leans out when I let off.
 
Last edited:

cekim

Large Member
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2007
Posts
6,445
Reaction score
38
Location
Earth
Not to jinx anything... but mine has sort of been doing it again. Not nearly to the extreme it was doing it, but I have noticed over the last couple of weeks that it has been leaning out when I let off the gas. If I push the clutch in it doesn't do it. But if I just let off and coast in gear it does. And the length of time it does it depends on how hard I was in the throttle before I let off. The harder I was in it, the longer it leans out when I let off.
Leaning out when you let off sounds pretty normal - particularly with the way the tune is setup on these things. The fuel really pulls back when you let off the gas. Using the engine to "brake" rather than just letting it idle down will increase this situation.

You can tune that out to a degree, but its generally not a big deal.
 

Hawgman

THE fucking bad guy
Staff member
Administrator
Super Moderator
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 4, 2007
Posts
14,472
Reaction score
954
Location
Texas
I agree. And am pretty used to seeing it do that. Just the last couple of weeks it has been lore than what i was used to seeing. Enough more that I noticed it..... if that makes sense. Probably just gun shy. Delt with that issue for so long that now any little twitch in the a/f I notice.
 

cekim

Large Member
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2007
Posts
6,445
Reaction score
38
Location
Earth
I agree. And am pretty used to seeing it do that. Just the last couple of weeks it has been lore than what i was used to seeing. Enough more that I noticed it..... if that makes sense. Probably just gun shy. Delt with that issue for so long that now any little twitch in the a/f I notice.
I hear you - after you blow an expensive part, you hear every rattle and moan of the new one...

I remember the first engine I built myself (after blowing the prior one), I swore I could hear each piston ring grinding up and down the cylinder bores:samuri:

After a while when it didn't blow up, I relaxed...
 

MikeVistaBlue06

Inventor: Asshole Points
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2007
Posts
2,169
Reaction score
31
Location
Richardson TX
I wonder if it is because they have them in the engine compartment next to the radiator and exhaust manifold?

All that heat may be causing premature failures.

I don't know why they don't put the computer inside the car where the environment isn't as harsh??

Mike
 

cekim

Large Member
S197 Team Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2007
Posts
6,445
Reaction score
38
Location
Earth
I don't know why they don't put the computer inside the car where the environment isn't as harsh??
My guess is some assembly process and/or the wiring length came down to 2 cents in the engine compartment or 3 cents in the pass compartment...

You _should_ be able to get "industrial" parts that can take that sort of heat without issue, but with the numbers of cars we are talking about it is not surprising to see an early revision failing with this frequency...
 

Support us!

Support Us - Become A Supporting Member Today!

Click Here For Details

Sponsor Links

Banner image
Back
Top