the extra 10mm isn't going to do that much for grip. if you're car isn't supercharged it's going to have a hard time spinning 285's in a 20 inch wheel. the compound of the tire is a lot more important to grip than the width. are you planning on autocrossing or doing trackdays with it?
if so, i'd go with 18's for the performance advantage and tire choice/prices. if not, 20's really do look sweet on the s197's
the blue car in this thread has TSW 20x10's with a 285 on the back and is lowered, not sure of the offset but its probably the same as the nurburgrings, so i'm thinking it'll fit
http://www.s197forum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=30034&page=22
here's some machined face 18's that a guy posted in the wheel and tire section