Most comfortable performance tire

[Nick93]

Hey all.. recently bought my 06 GT and the previous owner put a set of sumitomo's on the car. I'm not sure if they are flat spotted from sitting for a while but the these tires are so noisy it is unbearable. I plan to replace them and i have narrowed it down to 2 choices: BF Goodrich G-force comp 2 A/S , or hankook ventus v12 evo 2. I do not plan to drive the car in the winter nor do I track it or anything crazy like that. Just looking for a good all around quiet performance tire. Which of these are best ? (I would go with Michelin but they are out of my price range) thanks !

 

[Nick93]

Second pic didn't upload :

 

[46addict]

Tires harden after six years and have a shelf life of ten years, so if your current tires' age fall anywhere between that, it may be time to replace them. Your tire choices you posted are comparing apples to oranges because one is all-season and the other is a summer tire. But with you being in a colder state it may be better to go with an all-season tire. Summer tires tend to crack when exposed to sub 40-degree temps. The BFGs you posted are good tires. I would also look at Continental ExtremeContact DWS06 and Cooper Zeon RS-3A. And have you thought about running a square setup? If you aren't racing the car I see no need to stagger tire sizes. Just a thought.

 

[Norm Peterson]

What width wheels are you working with? That will define the upper limit on tire size.

If they're 18x8.5's all around, 255/45 is as wide as you should go (275's really need to be on 9's or wider), and there doesn't look to be much in 265/45-18 (8.5" wide rim, minimum) that you'd be interested in. If they're only 18x8's, even 255/45's make me a little uneasy.


Norm

 

[Brandon08GT]

I have the BF Goodrich on my 20 inch wheels and I like them a lot. Hook well for an all season, work great in the rain (we get a lot here in Florida) and there isn’t any noticeable noise.

 

[AndrewNagle]

Continental DWS06 are what I am running 275/40r18 on all four corners and am very happy. I have MPSS for summer only

Here is what I found on tire rack in your siZes

 

[Norm Peterson]

Nick93 -
a stock/stockish 4.6L isn't powerful enough to need staggered tire sizes for the driving that you have listed. I ran 255/45's (Goodyear Asymmetrics, on 18x9.5's) on all four corners for several years and that size was entirely adequate for everything up to and including autocross and intermediate-level track time, with no adverse street-duty consequences at all. I have a sneaking suspicion that design of the S197 may have even had that size in mind (it did end up on the front of the '08 GT500 that I know of directly).


Norm

 

[Nick93]

What width wheels are you working with? That will define the upper limit on tire size.

If they're 18x8.5's all around, 255/45 is as wide as you should go (275's really need to be on 9's or wider), and there doesn't look to be much in 265/45-18 (8.5" wide rim, minimum) that you'd be interested in. If they're only 18x8's, even 255/45's make me a little uneasy.


Norm

They are staggered SVE wheels, 9 in the front and 10 in the rear. I am thinking of going with the hankooks because of price but I would prefer all seasons.

 

[Nick93]

I have the BF Goodrich on my 20 inch wheels and I like them a lot. Hook well for an all season, work great in the rain (we get a lot here in Florida) and there isn’t any noticeable noise.

I may end up going with those because I would prefer all seasons. Thanks for the input!

 

[46addict]

Most wheels that are sold through Mustang wheel & parts outlets can be bought in 10" width for the front and rear with no clearance issues. Going beyond a 275 width tire on a 10" rim may touch the struts or swaybar endlinks on the front but 255s on SVE wheels should be a good fit.

In short, no need to stagger if you get 10" width on both ends.

 

[Norm Peterson]

They are staggered SVE wheels, 9 in the front and 10 in the rear. I am thinking of going with the hankooks because of price but I would prefer all seasons.

For that you might want to consider 285/40's for the rear. 275/40 is slightly shorter than 255/45 (around 10mm shorter on the diameter) and you might not care for the appearance if you're at all picky about that sort of thing.


Norm

 

[RocketcarX]

Michelin.

 

[msvela448]

I know you said Michelin was out of your price range.... But.... Michelin is the tire you want to run. The Pilot Super Sports are great tires and the Sport Cup 2 are even better.

Sent from my A0001 using Tapatalk

 

[Norm Peterson]

OP is in NJ, as I am. The Pilot Super Sport remains at least decently grippy down into the 20°'s F, but they do not cope with snow/slush very well at all. They're a "go-to" choice for rain that isn't freezing. They actually provide a decent ride.


Norm

 

[DiMora]

Michelins are the way to go, but I would go BFG if I could not run Michelins.

 

[frank s]

The trouble with committing to a price-determined tire is that you'll always have that echo in your head: "Gee, I coulda had ..."

 

[Pentalab]

Spend once, cry once, be done with it. That puny contact patch is the only thing between 3900 lbs..and the asphalt.

 

[fast Ed]

Continental Extreme Contact Sport is a close runner-up to the Michelin PSS, and in many sizes is a fair amount less $$. Plus it's available in sizes like 255/45R18 and 285/40R18, which are getting less common in the max performance category.


cheers
Ed

 

[ixtlan]

Im running the Conti now and really like them. I am really impressed with the snow and ice traction with them since where I am that is very important. The traction in dry conditions is really nice too. My only suggestion is that they add a belt or two to the sidewall to stiffen up the cornering flex. But I run a taller sidewall so that has an effect on it. I had Michelins on before and they did great on dry and wet pavement, but really lacked in the snow and ice arena. Mt other complaint was the wear life was really poor. I got 22k and they were almost bald.

 

[Pentalab]

Was that MPSS ??